Introduction
Before he became a country music legend, Conway Twitty first captured the world’s attention with a rock and roll ballad that pierced the soul: “It’s Only Make Believe.” Released in 1958, this song quickly rose to the top of the charts and solidified Twitty’s place in music history.
In this post, we’ll take a closer look at the song’s origins, lyrical meaning, success story, and why it still resonates more than six decades later.
The Origin of “It’s Only Make Believe”
Co-written by Conway Twitty and Jack Nance, “It’s Only Make Believe” was recorded in Memphis, Tennessee and released by MGM Records. At the time, Twitty was still a relative newcomer trying to break through the crowded 1950s rock scene.
The song was initially slow to gain traction in the U.S., but after gaining popularity in Canada and the UK, it shot to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 in November 1958—Twitty’s first and only chart-topping pop hit in America.
Lyrics: The Pain of Pretend Love
At its core, “It’s Only Make Believe” is about unrequited love. The narrator loves someone deeply, but the affection isn’t returned—yet he pretends it is. The irony is heartbreaking:
“My one and only prayer
Is that someday you’ll care
My hopes, my dreams come true
My one and only you…”
It’s not just a song; it’s a confession—a raw, vulnerable portrayal of a man living in fantasy because the truth is too painful to bear.
A Crossroads Between Rock and Country
While many today associate Conway Twitty with country ballads like “Hello Darlin’” or “You’ve Never Been This Far Before,” this song marked his roots in the rock and roll era.
His smooth voice, powerful delivery, and heartfelt emotion in “It’s Only Make Believe” drew comparisons to Elvis Presley, and the song became a blueprint for future rock ballads with its blend of vulnerability and melodic strength.
Cultural Impact and Legacy
Over the years, “It’s Only Make Believe” has been covered by dozens of artists, including:
-
Glen Campbell
-
Billy Fury
-
Ronnie McDowell
-
Bonnie Tyler
Its lasting impact is a testament to the song’s universal theme and emotional power. For many fans, it marks the beginning of Conway Twitty’s incredible journey from teen idol to country music icon.
Why It Still Resonates Today
Songs about pretend love and hidden heartbreak will never go out of style. In an age of social media masks and curated relationships, “It’s Only Make Believe” feels more relevant than ever. It’s a reminder that not all love stories are mutual—and that sometimes, the most beautiful songs come from the deepest sorrow.
Final Thoughts
“It’s Only Make Believe” is more than just a vintage hit—it’s an emotional time capsule. Whether you’re discovering Conway Twitty for the first time or revisiting the classics, this song is a must-listen. It’s heartfelt, timeless, and utterly unforgettable.
Lyrics: It’s Only Make Believe
People see us everywhere
They think you really care
But myself, I can’t deceive
I know it’s only make believeMy one and only prayer
Is that someday you’ll care
My hopes, my dreams come true
My one and only youNo one will ever know
How much I love you so
My only prayer will be
Someday you’ll care for me
But it’s only make believeMy hopes, my dreams come true
My life I’d give for you
My heart, a wedding ring
My all, my everythingMy heart I can’t control
You rule my very soul
My only prayer will be
Someday you’ll care for me
But it’s only make believeMy one and only prayer
Is that some day you’ll care
My hopes, my dreams come true
My one and only youNo one will ever know
How much I love you so
My prayers, my hopes, my schemes
You are my every dream
But it’s only make believe (make believe)
